There is a Shitta that nowadays that we don’t have Techailes we should not wear
Tzitzis at all. That Techailes is M’akeiv Es Halavan. This is the opinion of
Rebbi in the Mishna and the Baal Hamor Paskens this way. However, we L’halacha
Pasken like the Chachamim and we all wear Lavan we all wear the white Tzitzis
despite the fact that we do not have Techailes or at least most of Klal Yisrael
for most of its history has not had Techailes. There is a Chumra and there are
Machmirim who will not wear Tzitzis out in the street on Shabbos and it is
based on the Shitta of the Baal Hamaor. They argue and say according to the
Baal Hamoer that Tzitzis must have Techailes and therefore, the white strings
would be carrying on Shabbos. It says in Shulchan Aruch that if you have
Tzitzis that are Posul, the strings are Posul it is considered carrying when
you wear them out in the street and those strings don’t belong there.
They argue the same thing here. If
you hold that Techailes is M’akeiv Es Halavan, on Shabbos wearing the Lavan
itself would be carrying. Ad Kan Chumra Zu.
I have a Kasha on this for a long
time. It is true that when Tzitzis are Posul one is carrying. Nevertheless,
even if in Shamayim they Pasken like Rebbi and one needs Techailes,
nevertheless wearing 8 strings that are white should not be carrying. This is
because carrying is based on what people consider a Tachshit (something that
people think belongs on a Beged). Even if it were an erroneous Psak and they
hold like the Chachamim nevertheless it cannot be carrying it is no different
than any design a person has on a Beged which is the way he intended it to be.
Therefore, this Chumra which is well known in Brisk circles in Eretz Yisrael
seems to be technically inaccurate.
אין תגובות:
הוסף רשומת תגובה